Rich (11/26): The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho

Coelho creates a world that we would all love to live in -- a world where persistence is rewarded and help from above is provided when it is needed. This idealism provides a sanctuary from the daily onslaught of bad news that dominates the headlines. But, can a story succeed when there is a back door to every corner? Do we need tragedy to appreciate success? The book's popularity provides evidence that readers don't need or want evil to balance good. For them, the outside world provides enough contrast. But, for me, "love at first sight" and living to fulfill one's "Personal Legend," Coelho-speak for destiny, is best left for fairy tales and graduation speeches.

Santiago, Coelho's orphan Annie, is a model citizen for the follow-your-dreams club. Even after being robbed of all his money and possessions, Santiago treats this affront with less remorse than getting a papercut. While noble that he can casually repel misfortune, he learns nothing from this episode. He instead places his complete faith in the words of the fortune teller, absolving himself of any responsibilty. Santiago, the shepard, becomes the sheep to his own "personal legend."